ok..really 3.5 stars I think. If Keira wasn't such a self absorbed you know what I would like this better. The love triangle in this is soooooooooooooo drawn out. Seriously make up your dang mind already. It was insanely frustrating. I liked the dynamic between Keira and Kellan though. I thought Kellan was awesome and I felt like the writing was done really really well in the sense that the scenes didn't have to be really graphic in order to convey what was happening. (sometimes I am a bit of prude and I don't need EVERY detail)It's hard for me to review or explain how I felt about this one. I didn't love it like the rest of the world apparently, but I did like it. I am not super excited about reading two more books with Keira....but I will because I don't like to leave things unfinished.